Concept:Carbonate ions produce a white precipitate with barium chloride, and the precipitate dissolves in dilute acid with effervescence due to carbon dioxide gas.
Solution:Adding
BaCl2(aq) to salt
X gives a white precipitate, which indicates the formation of an insoluble barium salt.
When dilute
HCl is added, the precipitate dissolves with rapid effervescence, showing that a gas is evolved.
For carbonate ions, the reactions are:
Ba2++CO32−→BaCO3(s) (white precipitate)
BaCO3(s)+2HCl(aq)→BaCl2(aq)+H2O(l)+CO2(g)The carbon dioxide gas released produces the observed effervescence.
Sulphate ions would form insoluble
BaSO4, which does not dissolve in dilute
HCl.
Nitrate ions do not form any precipitate with
BaCl2, because barium trioxonitrate(V) is soluble.
Key point: A sulphite also gives a white precipitate (
BaSO3) that dissolves in dilute HCl, but the gas it gives,
SO2, is very soluble in water and is identified by its choking smell, not by brisk fizzing. Rapid effervescence of an odourless gas is the mark of a carbonate.
Answer:Option D (
CO32− ions)