Concept:First ionization energy generally increases across period 3 because the nuclear charge rises while the shielding stays almost the same. There is one exception in this group of elements: phosphorus has a half-filled
3p subshell (
3p3), which is extra stable, while sulphur (
3p4) has one paired
3p electron that is repelled by its partner and is removed more easily. So
S has a slightly lower ionization energy than
P.
Data (first ionization energy, kJ mol−1):Al=578,
Si=787,
S=1000,
P=1012Solution:Increasing order:
Al<Si<S<P, i.e. Al, Si, S, P.
Key point: The paper and its key give Al, Si, P, S (option C), which follows only the general trend and ignores the P/S anomaly. No printed option was correct, so option D (printed "P, Si, S, Al") has been replaced by the correct order Al, Si, S, P.
Answer:Option D (Al, Si, S, P)